Identifying Non-Ethical Behaviour in Retail Business

Walk into any market or mall, and most transactions happen on trust. You trust that the price on the tag is the real price, that the product is genuine, that the staff are treated fairly, and that what you buy is safe to use. Non-ethical behaviour in retail is what happens when that trust is quietly broken, sometimes through small shortcuts and sometimes through serious crimes. Recognising these practices is the first step toward running a business that lasts and protecting yourself as a customer. This post breaks down the most common forms of unethical conduct in retail, from breaking labour laws to selling fake goods, and explains why each one matters.

Violating labour and operational laws 🔗

Every shop operates within a legal framework that governs when it can open, how long staff can work, and who is allowed to work at all. Ignoring these rules is one of the most basic forms of unethical retail conduct. A common violation is keeping a store open beyond the hours permitted by law to squeeze out extra sales.

In India, retail outlets are regulated mainly by state-level Shop and Establishment Acts, which set rules for working hours, rest intervals, opening and closing times, weekly holidays, and overtime. Because there is no single central law for shops, the exact rules vary from one state to another, but they all share the same purpose of protecting workers and customers.

Employing children and young persons 🔗

The most serious labour violation is putting children to work. The Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act, 1986, as amended in 2016, prohibits employment of children below 14 years in almost all occupations, with narrow exceptions for family enterprises. Young persons aged 14 to 18 face restricted working hours, typically capped at around six hours a day, and cannot be made to work night shifts. A retailer who hires a child to stock shelves or run errands is not just cutting costs unethically; they are breaking the law and harming a child’s future.

Deceptive product information and pricing 🔗

Pricing and labelling are where retail ethics are tested every single day. Customers make decisions based on what is printed on the tag and the package. When that information is manipulated, the customer is effectively cheated.

Misleading price stickering and hidden charges 🔗

Improper price stickering is a classic trick. A retailer might place a new sticker over the original printed price, charge more than the Maximum Retail Price, or display one price on the shelf and ring up another at the counter. Many deceptive practices are not technically false but simply hide the fine print, such as a “free” offer that quietly adds processing fees or a discount that applies only under conditions buried in small text. Hidden charges added at billing fall into the same category. The customer agreed to one price and is made to pay another.

Withholding product information 🔗

Deliberately concealing details like ingredients, expiry dates, country of origin, or known side effects is another form of deception. This is especially dangerous with food, cosmetics, and medicines, where a missing ingredient list can lead a customer with an allergy straight into harm. Under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, the right to information is a core consumer right, meaning shoppers are entitled to know the quality, quantity, purity, and price of what they buy.

Internal misconduct and theft 🔗

Not all unethical behaviour is aimed at customers. A large share of it happens inside the store, carried out by the people who run it. This is one of the biggest hidden drains on a retail business.

Internal misconduct takes many forms: employees misusing company assets, pocketing cash, stealing merchandise, or manipulating billing. One sneaky practice is when a salesperson charges a customer the full price for an item that is actually on sale, then keeps the difference. The customer never knows they were overcharged, and the business never sees the money.

The scale of this problem is striking. Indian retail has long recorded some of the highest rates of shrinkage in the world, with employee theft accounting for a significant share of losses. Shrinkage is the gap between recorded inventory and what is actually on the shelves, and it is driven heavily by both staff theft and customer shoplifting. For one Tata-owned retail chain, shrinkage rose to 0.41 per cent of sales in FY24, almost double the previous year, showing how quickly these losses can grow.

Exploitative sales and palming off 🔗

Some retailers knowingly take advantage of customers who cannot easily judge quality on their own. Selling low-quality or substandard merchandise while presenting it as good value is exploitative, particularly when the customer has no way to test the product before buying.

What “palming off” means 🔗

Palming off is a specific and serious offence. It involves selling pirated, counterfeit, or fake goods as if they came from a legitimate, branded manufacturer. A customer pays for what they believe is an authentic product and receives an imitation. The sale of counterfeit and adulterated goods is one of the central malpractices that consumer protection law is designed to stop. Beyond cheating the buyer, palming off damages the genuine brand and can expose customers to unsafe products made without any quality control.

Deceptive advertising and sales practices 🔗

Advertising is meant to inform, but it is frequently used to mislead. A retailer crosses an ethical line when it makes false claims about a product, exaggerates its benefits, or stays silent about an important limitation during the sales pitch.

A misleading advertisement under Section 2(28) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, includes one that gives a false description, offers a false guarantee, or deliberately conceals important information. Honesty by omission matters as much as honesty in what is said. If a salesperson leaves out a key fact, such as a product nearing expiry or a warranty that does not cover normal use, the omission is itself deceptive.

How advertising is regulated 🔗

India regulates advertising through two main channels. The Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI) is a self-regulatory body whose code requires advertisements to be truthful, honest, and not misleading by ambiguity or implication. Its Consumer Complaints Council reviews complaints and can recommend that an advertisement be withdrawn. On the statutory side, the Central Consumer Protection Authority holds investigative, recall, and penalty powers, and can impose fines and even ban endorsers of false advertisements. The takeaway for any retailer is simple: every claim should be something you can actually prove.

Customer and employee fraud 🔗

Fraud in retail flows in both directions. Customers commit it, and so do employees, and both inflict real damage on a business.

Shoplifting and return abuse 🔗

Shoplifting is the most visible form of customer fraud, and it remains a constant pressure on Indian stores. Shoplifting, where customers take merchandise without paying, sits alongside employee theft as a leading cause of shrinkage. Less obvious is return fraud, where unscrupulous return practices are used to extract refunds dishonestly, such as returning used, stolen, or worn merchandise. These losses are hard to detect because they accumulate quietly across the year.

Falsifying sales figures 🔗

On the employee side, staff may wrongfully report sales figures for personal gain. This can mean inflating numbers to earn higher commissions or incentives, voiding genuine sales to pocket cash, or manipulating records to hide theft. Such fraud distorts the very data a business relies on to make decisions, making it doubly harmful.

Environmental irresponsibility and safety violations 🔗

Ethical retailing extends beyond the cash counter to the wider impact a store has on people and the planet. Two areas stand out here: environmental harm and safety.

Environmentally unfriendly practices 🔗

Using banned plastic bags or other environmentally harmful packaging, even after such items have been restricted, is an ethical and often legal breach. Retailers play a direct role in how much waste reaches the environment, and ignoring greener alternatives shifts that cost onto society.

Selling unsafe or expired products 🔗

The most dangerous violation is selling expired or substandard goods. Stocking products past their expiry date, or selling items that fail basic safety norms, puts customers at direct physical risk. Consumer law in India guarantees a right to safety, and a buyer who receives a defective or hazardous product can seek repair, replacement, refund, or compensation, and can demand that the unsafe product be pulled from sale. A retailer who knowingly sells such goods is gambling with someone’s health to clear old stock.

Across all these categories, a clear pattern emerges. Unethical retail behaviour usually starts as a small shortcut to save money or boost short-term sales, but it erodes the trust that brings customers back. Businesses that resort to unfair practices invite government action and damage their own reputation, while those that play fair tend to win in the long run.

What do you think? If you ran a small retail store under tight margins, where would you draw the line between an aggressive sales tactic and an unethical one? And as a customer, which of these practices do you think you have unknowingly experienced?

References

1. https://www.indiafilings.com/learn/shop-and-establishment-act-india
2. https://www.india-briefing.com/doing-business-guide/india/human-resources-and-payroll/labor-law
3. https://hyring.com/free-hr-toolkit/hr-glossary/shops-and-establishments-act
4. https://righttoinformation.wiki/misleading-advertisement-complaint-india
5. https://www.mondaq.com/india/consumer-law/1567002/consumer-rights-under-the-consumer-protection-act-2019-empowering-consumers-for-a-fair-marketplace
6. https://www.business-standard.com/article/companies/indian-retail-lost-rs-9-295-to-shoplifting-theft-110112400049_1.html
7. https://www.business-standard.com/industry/news/shoplifting-employee-theft-indian-retail-firms-see-rise-in-shrinkage-124061500403_1.html
8. https://cuet.iitk.ac.in/sathee-cuet/student-corner/ncert-books/class-12/business-studies/chapter-11-consumer-protection/
9. https://blog.ipleaders.in/advertisement-standards-council-india-asci/
10. https://www.taxtmi.com/article/detailed?id=14226
11. https://www.indianretailer.com/article/retail-business/retail/solutions-shrinkage-retails-biggest-pain
12. https://www.ncib.in/consumer-rights-protection.php
13. https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/articles/consumer-protection-law-a-general-study-from-india-s-perspective-16818.asp